Voting Machine Makers Claim The Names Of The Entities That Own Them Are Trade Secrets
Failures
from the yeah-this-makes-you-all-look-way-less-shady dept
Wed, Jul 10th 2019 9:24am — Tim Cushing

Recently, the North Carolina State Board of Elections asked suppliers of electronic voting machines a simple question: who owns you? (h/t Annemarie Bridy)
On June 14, 2019, the State Board of Elections requested that your companies disclose any owners or shareholders with a 5% or greater interest or share in each of the vendor’s company, any subsidiary company, of the vendor, and the vendor’s parent company.

This seems like very basic information -- information the Board should know and should be able to pass on to the general public. After all, these are the makers of devices used by the public while electing their representatives. They should know who's running these companies and who their majority stakeholders are. If something goes wrong (and something always does), they should know who's ultimately responsible for the latest debacle.

It's not like the state was asking the manufacturers to cough up code and machine schematics. All it wanted to know is the people behind the company nameplates. But the responses the board received indicate voting system manufacturers believe releasing any info about their companies' compositions will somehow compromise their market advantage.

Hart Intercivic said letting the public know that the company is owned by H.I.G. Hart, LLC and Gregg L. Burt is a fact that would devalue the company if it were made public.
    Hart InterCivic, a corporation that derives independent actual value from this information not being generally known or readily ascertainable and makes reasonable efforts to maintain the secrecy of this information, requests that it be designated as a trade secret pursuant to G.S. § 132-1.2(1)d. and G.S. § 66-152(3).


Election Systems & Software (ES&S) said basically the same thing, claiming this information is "proprietary and confidential information:"
    The following individuals and/or entities own 5% or more of the shares of Government Systems, Software & Services, Inc.:
    McCarthy Group, LLC
    Tom Burt
    Tom O'Brien

Clear Ballot also claimed its list of owners was a trade secret:
    Hello, per your request please see below for a list of our shareholders with a 5% or greater share of Clear Ballot Group, Inc. We have no other parent companies or subsidiaries:
    1. Larry Moore
    2. Tim Halvorsen
    3. Steven Papa
    4. Raging Capital Opportunity Fund V, LLC

page 1