>>/3794/
> Imagine putting an AI powered drone on the guild's orb. Will it be able to tell if the drone is good or evil?
Technically and legally guns don't kill people, people do, accidents included. Even a remote trap involving a gun would have been set up by someone who may have just been negligent. A gun does not have a soul, and a gun is not evil.
By extension even though a dwemer automaton was created by arguably evil people, it is not itself evil the programmers were. Imprisoning a dwemer automaton is an absurd judgement for the deaths it caused or crimes it committed.
So we say, can a soulless creation be used for good or evil? Yes. Can it be programed or used for evil deeds? Yes. Who then is responsible for a deed you do that is deemed evil? Yulya, the party leader.
So imagine you committed evil while part of Yulya's party?
https://youtube.com/watch?v=0GDA0tRftmY [Embed]
Then prove to me you are evil by doing evil deeds while under the command of a saintly person. That may show that it is you that are evil and not her fault.
Then return to the orb and they'll decide who was at fault. It wouldn't likely be a ruling the Adventurers guild can make. The orb has extra-material connections to gods that inhabit other planes of existence, you may be deemed guilty or Yulya will, but be prepared for a judgment that brings upon you the most heinous consequences possible and in that case they may find you at fault and punish Yulya anyway.
Alternatively, you would be captured and dismantled by placing your fluids in three separate jars (as part of the conditions I already set) and used as evidence in Yulya's trial in the material plane. The defense may argue Yulya's is not at fault because you, the fluid in question did the deed independently, but the prosecution will argue that soulless creations cannot themselves be held liable and sight hundreds of cases in their deposition.
I'm sorry but as your judge I would have to side with the prosecution in that case so Yulya's only option would be to plea to gross negligence and take partial responsibility for the crimes committed. At that point she will serve out her sentence, be banished from Faerûn or be executed.
You would then either be separated into hundreds of portions and cast into inert crystalline prisons of glass or other materials you are not capable of dissolving, and entombed SCP style.